 |
Measurement: Developmental
Research and Theory
Measurement
comprises a set of understandings and skills
that form a foundation for essential learning,
especially in science and mathematics. These
understandings and skills routinely come into
play in everyday life and as preparation for
further investigation of other topicsfractions,
proportion, area and volume, and density to
name a few. The importance of measurement is
underscored by the array of math science standards
for which it forms the basic underpinning. This
is discussed at length as both narrative and
cited examples in national and state mathematics
and science education standards documents.
Measurement Understandings,
Skills, and Conceptual Growth
Most of what we know regarding measurementespecially
linear measurement, the most basic building
block of conceptual understanding of measurementis
based either directly or indirectly on studies
by Piaget and his colleagues. As of publication
of NCTM's Principles and Standards for School
Mathematics (NCTM, 2000), Piaget's definition
of measurement as the synthesis of subdivision
(i.e., understanding that space or an object's
length can be "partitioned") and change
of position (i.e., being able to partition a
unit from an object and iterate that unit without
gaps or overlaps) (Piaget & Inhelder, 1956;
Piaget et al., 1960) remains intact. The term
"synthesis" has special meaning, as
it refers to the ability to coordinate understanding
and application of the two and to furthermore
do so with insightnot randomly, or by
trial and error, or even as an act of accurate
measurement when done only by formalized steps
devoid of meaning and interpretation. The importance
of this notion is further supported by the Principles
and Standards for School Mathematics. The
concepts of inclusion and conservation of length
are implicit in this view of measurementthey
form as well the most sound developmental continua
of which we are aware, as both have been found
to grow as a child learns to measure (Inhelder,
Sinclair, & Bovet, 1974). The question of the
influence of one on the other, and by default
the order in which each is realized, is a matter
of debate. Of significance, however, is that
the close correlation of the concepts of inclusion
and conservation of length with the act of measuring
has resulted in our ability to categorize children's
development of measurement concepts into several
stages (Piaget et al., 1960; Carpenter, 1976;
Copeland, 1974; and Sinclair, 1970). The following
illustrates the distinctions between stages
based on their progress in their understanding
and ability to appropriately apply these concepts.
|
Early
Stage (younger than 6 years old) - The
child cannot conserve length, but rather
relies only on visual perception. At this
stage, the child does not understand length
as a fixed attribute of an object. For
example, when two objects of equal length
are placed beside each other, with their
endpoints aligned, the child may recognize
that they are of the same length, but
when one or both of the objects are moved
so that the endpoints do not align, the
child will no longer recognize their equality.
Likewise, the child cannot reason transitivelyhe/she
is not able to use a third object of a
certain length (e.g., stick, ruler, yardstick,
or even his/her own body) to compare the
lengths of two other objects. In the child's
mind, once the third object is moved,
it changes length. As with the notion
of length, understanding of "space"
also eludes the child at the early stagehe/she
does not perceive objects with well-defined
spatial relations as fixed attributes.
The child therefore cannot exhibit reversibility.
For example, the child will not recognize
that the distance (the empty space between
two objects) from fixed point A to fixed
point B is the same as the distance from
point B to A.
Transitional
Stage (ages 6-8) - The child can conserve
length. The child typically begins at
ages 6-7 to exhibit the ability to reason
transitively by using his/her own body
as the third objectthe referentto
compare the lengths of two other objects.
With increased understanding of length
as a fixed attribute of an object, the
child at ages 7-8 exhibits understanding
that an object can be partitioned (subdivision),
the whole is the sum of its parts, and
that a fixed unit (other objects or a
ruler, for example) of length can be iterated
along the length of an objector
over a distancewithout gaps or overlaps,
in either direction (reversibility), and
that the "change of position"
does not change the length of the referent.
Operational
Stage (ages 8-10) - The child understands
the concept of inclusionwhen iterating
a unit across a distance or length, the
distance covered by the first unit is
nested in the distance covered by two
units, and so on. The child synthesizes
and coordinates understanding and application
of both subdivision and change of location,
and does so with insight. Children with
this ability can typically compare relative
distances and express one distance in
terms of the other (e.g., length A is
half as long as length B, and so forth),
coordinate units of different lengths
in unique spatial environments, and recognize
accumulation of distance (e.g., quantitative
measurements represent a series of nested
distances).
|
Carpenter,
T. (1976). Analysis and synthesis on existing
research on measurement. In R. Lesh & D. Bradford
(Eds.), Number and measurement. [Papers
from a research workshop]. (ERIC Document Reproduction
Service No. ED 120027)
Copeland,
R. (1974). How children learn mathematics:
Teaching implications of Piaget's research
(2nd ed.). New York: Macmillan.
Inhelder,
B., Sinclair, H., & Bovet, M. (1974). Learning
and the development of cognition. Cambridge,
MA: Harvard University Press.
Piaget,
J., & Inhelder, B. (1956). The child's conception
of space. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Piaget,
J., Inhelder, B., & Szeminska, A. (1960). The
child's conception of geometry. New York:
Basic Books.
National
Council of Teachers of Mathematics (2000). Principles
and standards for school mathematics. Reston,
VA: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
Sinclair,
H. (1970). Number and Measurement. In M. Rosskopf,
L. Steffe, & S. Taback (Eds.), Piagetian
cognitive-development research and mathematical
education (pp. 135-149). Washington, DC:
National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
If
this is your first time
to visit LearningLeads, or if it
has been awhile, be sure to take a look at the
LearningLeads
homepage at: http://www.designedinstruction.com/learningleads/index.html
For
more on measurement, go to the Measurement,
Geometry, and Spatial Sense curriculum and
learning strand overview page at: http://www.designedinstruction.com/learningleads/measurement-geometry.html
If
you teach or have colleagues who work with preschoolers,
go to the PreKorner
homepage to browse similar resources, at:
http://www.designedinstruction.com/prekorner/index.html
You
may be particularly interested in the early
childhood numeracy resources, at: http://www.designedinstruction.com/prekorner/early-numeracy.html
|
LearningLeads
- Measurement: Developmental Research and Theory (print-friendly html version)

LearningLeads is a trademark of Designed Instruction,
LLC. All rights reserved. Please read our notices
and policies. Navigation? See sitemap.
Questions? Contact
us.
|
|